Amish Friendship Bread: More Than Just Delicious

Amish Friendship Bread

By Angela Noel

April 27, 2017

My mother-in-law, Karry, makes a bread that tastes like the intersection of pound cake, cinnamon sugar donuts, and the best thing I’ve ever eaten in my life. It’s so good, my son wanted me to save some so he could invite his friends over for a slice, and my husband and I had an uncomfortable stand-off over who should eat the last piece. (He won—but only because I didn’t tell him I wanted it. I just stared at him while he popped the crumbly, chocolate chip-studded morsel into his mouth.)

This evanescent bread, a variant of Amish Friendship Bread, has a mission beyond being delicious.

Surprising no one, I hungered (pun intended) for more.

What’s Done is Done?

After quizzing Karry and searching the internet, I learned the friendship element of the bread comes from the tradition of sharing not only loaves of the finished product, but a bit of the starter as well. This sharing business–of first spending ten days tending the starter, reserving some of it to use for next time, then giving some away–caught my attention. Some of the articles I read compared the practice to a chain letter, but I disagree. Instead, I see it as a metaphor for life.

Amish Friendship Bread Recipe
Karry’s well-loved Amish Friendship Bread recipe. The key, says Karry, is using TWO packages of pudding.

The recipe for starter begins with combining at least three basic ingredients: flour, sugar, and milk. (You can also use baker’s yeast.) Then you knead and feed the mixture for the allotted time until it’s ready to take part in the magical process of bread making. In baking, you typically make something. But not starter. You don’t make a starter, you nurture it.

We call many things done when they reach a final, stable state. I’m done with the dishes, for instance, when I’ve either broken them all, or they’re clean. A starter is done, however, when it’s ready to be shared or transformed into something else.

Different from gifts of money, acts of charity, how-to books, or volunteering in the traditional sense, creating and offering starter to others assumes a collaboration between what is, and what could be. It starts with one creative person and passes forward, morphing and developing in new and wondrous ways. I’ve been lucky enough to come across several examples of this kind of starter recently.

Or, perhaps because I was looking for them, they found me.

Creative Collaboration

Traci Cavanaugh York
An example of Traci’s handiwork. Check out her blog and contribute your own quote!

Traci Cavanaugh York posted an offer on her blog this week: Send her a favorite quote and she’ll pair it with one of the photographs in her collection. (Read her post here.) She wants to do more with her photos–she wants us to do more with them.

Bakers already know this, but the magic of starter dough (when you’re not using baker’s yeast) comes from the natural, albeit invisible, bacteria in the air. Create an enticing environment for these bacteria and chemical hocus pocus occurs.  Traci’s invitation attracts others she can’t necessarily see–like me–to contribute to her creations. She wants collaboration, and wants the result of the collaboration to be more than it could have been had either of us acted on our own.

A Willing Recipient

I call this next example my Twitter angel story. A fellow writer and I shared a few tweets back and forth some months ago. She’d told me at some point that she’d attended a writer’s conference or two. The week before I planned to attend my first conference I asked her for some pointers. Not only did she offer advice and moral support, she gave me so much more.

Selling a novel to literary agents requires a particular skill I’ve yet to master. In the course of our conversation, she politely asked if I’d like her help with my marketing materials. Past midnight on a Friday, she edited, suggested, critiqued, and cajoled my words–transforming them from a passable product into an intriguing invitation.

I call her my Twitter angel because without her I couldn’t see where I’d gone wrong. This expert friend used the raw ingredients of what I had, and helped me make it better. She worked hard, and expected I would do the same. In fact, she asked for my buy-in up front before she edited a word. This step can mean the difference between a successful, joyful collaboration, and a mess of pointless goo.

A bubbling jar of starter
A bubbling jar of starter.
Photo by basykes and licensed through Creative Commons

The articles on Friendship Bread extol its virtues but warn a gift of starter should be carefully considered. “Everyone will eat the bread, but not everyone wants a bag or a jar of this stuff,” Karry explained with a smile. The bubbling, needy mix can confer an unwanted or unintended obligation. Some gifts, like advice and starter, are best offered when the receiver is willing and able to act on it.

Offered with Love, Not Judgment

No one learned this lesson more powerfully than a queer, muslim woman in Bahrain named Esra’a. Fearing violence in a culture where the law won’t protect her, she doesn’t appear in public in her activist persona. She took to the internet instead, founding a website, People can ask questions, and share their feelings–sometimes raw and painful–to get honest answers without judgment. Aiming to open minds through dialogue, she offers first-hand knowledge in a loving and simple way, believing the act of collaboration and shared experiences will bring change.

So, as I look at this gift, this bread, and what it represents, I see more than just delicious snack food. The combination of ingredients–those found in our kitchens or those we find in ourselves–nurtured over time and then shared with others creates amazing, often delightful, results. A starter is the beginning of something, each of us decides what we do next.

Your turn: What kinds of starters can you think of or have you observed?

Author: Angela Noel

On a quest to become a better human, I write about parenting, leadership, and personal development. I tell my stories so you can find your own.

14 thoughts on “Amish Friendship Bread: More Than Just Delicious”

  1. I haven’t had Friendship bread in years! What an awesome parallel you’ve created with starters, and I’m beyond honored and tickled that you’ve included my quote project here! Thanks so much, Angela!

  2. I just wanted to share with you that whilst I was reading this wonderful post my Mother-in-law arrived with cake that she had baked, for all of us to share and my mother-in-law’s name? Carrie.

  3. Ooh, I love this post. I never would have guessed the twist in it when I read your first paragraph.

    Amish friendship bread sounds delicious. Your advice was even better. 🙂

  4. I remember sharing Friendship Bread years ago, when my kids were young. Such a fabulous idea. Just like your Twitter Angel. 🙂

    1. She really is amazing. I think so much of life is “transactional” that when we find chances to collaborate, over bread, writing, or whatever, the ability to contribute without the whole “what’s in it for me” is truly priceless. Thanks for reading!

  5. Many years ago several of the moms in the community shared Friendship Bread. It was fun, unique, and special to be included in the tradition. For months at a time I would have this jar of “goo” on the counter fermenting to become part of another wonderful loaf. Your words brought a whole new meaning to “the starter”. Thanks for the memories, along with a hankering for a slice (or 2).

    1. I didn’t know you had a Friendship Bread circle (I thought it was just Bunko :0) What a fun new thing to learn about you! All we need is a gluten-free variety, now. Someone should get to work on that.

  6. Pingback: Guest Post: Amish Friendship Bread: More Than Just Delicious | The Recipe Hunter

I love hearing from you! Please share your thoughts.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.